Skip to Content

3 Unique Shopping Experiences in Wayne County Ohio

Tonya Prater, Owner

3 Unique Shopping Experiences in Wayne County OhioWayne County is probably best known for its location on the edge of Amish Country, and for good reason. It’s common to see a horse and buggy along the back roads near the communities of Kidron, Dalton and Orrville. Those same small towns also offer unique shopping experiences, often as a result of the Mennonite or Amish communities. The founders of Smuckers, P. Graham Dunn and Lehman’s Hardware Store all come from a Mennonite background.

Shopping in Wayne County Ohio

J.M. Smuckers in Orrville, Ohio is the flagship Smuckers store with hundreds of products in a unique shopping environment

J.M. Smucker Company Store & Cafe

The J.M. Smucker Company Store & Cafe, the flagship store of the popular 115-year old company, boasts an impressive shopping facility that showcases Smucker’s signature items and those in the Smucker’s family line of products. One of my favorite attractions in the area, you’ll find the Pillsbury Doughboy ready to join you in a selfie, an interactive museum that shares the Smucker’s story and a tasting station. That’s right, you can taste everything in the store before you buy. How handy is that?

P. Graham Dunn offers inspirational art selections, home decor, clothing items and kids items.

P. Graham Dunn

A few minutes down the road, visible from Route 30, you’ll find P. Graham Dunn, an 18,000 square foot retail store full of inspirational art, gifts, home décor, Ohio State merchandise and clothing. The beautiful second floor showroom provides windows so guests can view the round-the-clock production that takes place in the factory on the ground floor. The company, which is celebrating their 40th year in business, caters to the Christian community as many of their pieces are inscribed with popular bible verses. They also have laser engravers that can engrave a large selection of products and provide customization while you wait. If you’re looking for a unique gift idea, this store has it.

Dalton Dari-ette Drive-in

When you leave P. Graham Dunn, stop at the Dalton Dari-ette Drive-in on the corner of U.S. Route 30 and Ohio Route 94 for an ice cream treat- just make sure you have a bit of cash on hand. If you don’t, you’ll find an ATM at the bank across the street.

Original Lehman's Hardware store front

Lehman’s Hardware Store

A gem of Wayne County is Lehman’s Hardware Store in nearby Kidron. Lehman’s started in 1955 by Jay Lehman to serve the Amish community. The store continues to be owned and operated by the Lehman family today and has grown from its humble beginnings to a store that is nearly ¾ of a mile long. You’ll find environmentally friendly products, hard to find goods and a large selection of items that are made in the U.S.A. From kitchen products, to retro candy, to canned bacon and composting toilets, don’t let the name ‘hardware store’ fool you- this stop will appeal to men and women, young and old. And for those silver haired visitors, you’ll experience a bit of nostalgia when viewing the antiques that are interspersed with the new items throughout the store.

The Glass-bottled soda display at Lehman's Hardware Store in Kidron, Ohio

Make sure you stop for a free sample of fudge, the Maple Nut is heavenly, check out the glass-bottled soda selection which includes 220 varieties with unique flavors such as bacon and sassafras, and get your photo taken inside the phone booth.

Apple fritters at the Quince Bakery and Cafe in Kidron, Ohio

Quince Bakery & Café

If you’re a serious shopper, you’ll probably work up an appetite so grab a bite to eat in the café or pop next door and just across the street to Quince Bakery & Café for healthy lunch options and decadent desserts that are made from scratch using locally sourced ingredients whenever possible. Once you’ve tasted the to die for apple fritters with caramel sauce, you’ll find yourself making excuses to visit Kidron as frequently as possible.

Next time you plan a trip to Ohio’s Amish Country, swing by Wayne County, check out these unique shops and then stop in Wooster for more one of a kind shopping and dining experiences. You can learn more about Wayne County at

Have you gone shopping in Wayne County? Which store would you enjoy most?

A special thanks to Green Door Media for inviting me to experience Wayne County. 

Did you enjoy this post? Read more about Wayne County:

Broken Rocks Cafe & Bakery specializes in fresh artisan bread and features in Italian-style dishes in downtown Wooster, Ohio.

Downtown Wooster: a City full of Surprises

The lobby of the St. Paul Hotel in Wooster Ohio is comfortable, stylish and contemporary.
St. Paul Hotel: a Boutique Hotel Experience in Downtown Wooster

The Sphinx at Worden's Ledges.
Looking for Things to do in Ohio? Look no further than the Ultimate Ohio Bucket List




Thursday 23rd of June 2016

That looks like a lot of fun. I love discovering new places! I'll have to check that out someday.

Nicole Escat

Friday 3rd of June 2016

We love smuckers at home, thanks for sharing this! I would love to see a smuckers shop here.

Ashley Brownell

Friday 3rd of June 2016

I have never been a fan of Ohio but this made it look a lot more enjoyable! Thank you for sharing!

Sarah Bailey

Thursday 2nd of June 2016

All of this looks like so much fun! I love older time places and that drive-in and the Smucker's Cafe looks awesome.

Kelly Hutchinson

Thursday 2nd of June 2016

What a unique and charming place to go shopping! I wish we had something like this where I live! Protection Status
This site uses cookies. Find out more about this site’s cookies.